Geek Dad: Amazon Echo vs Google Home Review and Comparison
This is a 100% honest, 100% authentic review comparison of the Amazon Echo and Google Home devices. Dadtography was not compensated in any way for this post.
Some banners and links below, marked as (af), may be affiliate links. Clicks on affiliate links provide a small percentage of each sale to Dadtography.com.
New tech comes out at the speed of light these days and one of the biggest trends is smart speaker digital voice assistants. Not only do they provide great sound quality for music streaming, but they act as a voice command-driven search tool and the center of a home automation plan as well. These devices are built with skills and also learn as they go. Considered by some to be just a trend at first, they're quickly becoming a must-have device for the home.
The great debate rages on of which smart device is best - Amazon Echo or Google Home. Our Amazon Echo vs Google Home head-to-head post seeks to answer that question from a geek dad's perspective.
Amazon Echo Review
Amazon's Smart Speaker & So Much More
Amazon's Echo device has a lot of things going for it, including being the first to market in the smart speaker device category.
Here's our list of Amazon Echo's key features and benefits:
- Google shopping rating of 4.6 stars (5k+ reviews)
- Bluetooth compatible
- Released June, 2015
- Voice Calls & Messages
- Extend with Echo Dot, Tap or Echo Show (af)
The Amazon is slightly larger (taller) and available in black or white. It's both taller and heavier than its Google Home competitor, but not by much.
When it comes to home automation (my primary area of interest for my device), the Echo (with Alexa) has an edge over the Google Home for the number of devices that it can control.
The Amazon Echo also has been measured to have a better WiFi connection than Google Home as well. That's most helpful in larger homes or ones with lots of obtrusive walls to get in the way.
Amazon Echo's Geek Dad Review Scoring
Amazon Echo Speaker0%
Amazon Alexa Compatibility0%
Amazon Echo WiFi Stability0%
Amazon Echo Price0%
Google Home Review
Google's Task Master
The Google Home device wasn't first to market, but it didn't come long after its Echo competitor. Google has made a number of updates to the device recently to make it even more competitive in the smart home device market.
Here's our updated list of key features and benefits of the Google Home:
- Google shopping rating of 4.4 stars (5k+ reviews)
- Bluetooth compatibility (recently added)
- Release October, 2016
- Versatile design options
- Deep integrations with TV's plus Chromecast
Compared to the Echo, the Google Home device is smaller (shorter) and lighter weight. The real physical differentiator is the styling options available for Google Home. While the Echo is available in black or white, the Google device has swappable bases available in multiple colors, including carbon, copper, mango, marine, slate, snow and violet.
Google Home Geek Dad Review Scoring
Google Home Speaker0%
Google Home Compatibility0%
Google Home WiFi Stability0%
Google Home Price0%
Google Home vs Amazon Echo - Final Thoughts
Both of these devices are really starting to live up to the original hype. As more and more compatible devices and "skills" or compatible features come out, they become more and more easy to justify. I'm personally very excited to see where they each are this same time next year.
Overall, the Amazon Echo has the edge in app compatibility and WiFi signal strength.
Google Home wins out on the speaker quality and price. Oh, and with the design options available for the Google Home, that's a differentiator as well.
The Geek Dad has to vote on compatibility, though, so the Amazon Echo wins out in our review. The more "stuff" you can do with your device, it's worth a few extra bucks. And if you want a pretty motif candle, then buy a pretty motif candle. If you want a smart home voice assistant, then buy an Echo.